Showing posts with label Chrystia Freeland. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chrystia Freeland. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 18, 2026

We desperately need another Nelson Mandela

This blog may seem rambling, because it is.  My belief is that everything is connected.  Unfortunately the weaknesses of mankind has a strangling influence.  Some of those in power cling to it with little regard to long term consequences.  Power has been centralized.  The rich get richer and the poor get poorer.  If something is not done (and soon) mankind seems destined for disaster.

Power is like a magnet for some individuals.  They visualize what they can accomplish with it.  Bigger house, nicer car, better clothes, more sexual choice.  Some enjoy obedience from everyone, even creating the fear of disobeying a whim.  Others fancy getting important things done ranging from lowering taxes to reducing crime to purifying the air.  Being important is a goal in itself.  Being above the law is intoxicating.  Controlling others allows one to indulge in fantasies.  To get power it sometimes is necessary to take advantage of prejudice and ignorance   http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2019/06/dying-of-whiteness.html

The Epstein Files, such as we know them, reveal that the very rich can indulge in sexual fantasies.  For some that means having sex with younger females or inflicting pain.  One man seems willing to use hurtful diversions to maintain his innocence.

Nelson Mandela, after suffering unfair imprisonment was so courageous and principled that he was eventually given power.  He was admired by enough people that he gained even more power.  He could easily have sought revenge or sought to enjoy all sorts of luxuries that he had been denied until he was almost too old to enjoy them.   He wanted the white South Africans to stay and developed the concept of truth and reconciliation and attracted the World Rugby Championship.  After his death I wrote a blog about Nelson Mandela.http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2013/12/nelson-mandela.html    A decade later I realized it took two men to change South Africa.   http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2024/09/we-need-another-nelson-mandela-and-fw.html

 There are still a lot of capable individuals who are honest and caring.  Unfortunately most of them lack sufficient power.  The people below are some examples of leaders who have demonstrated leadership.

Barrack Obama used Abraham Lincoln as a sort of model.  Both men prefer a team of advisors that would challenge them.  Doris Kearns Goodwin noted that Abraham Lincoln deliberately developed a team of rivals.   http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2011/11/team-of-rivals-has-lessons-for-today.html

It was pretty nervy for Pete Buttigieg, a small town mayor who was openly gay to run in a presidential leadership contest.  Somehow he proved to be well tempered, remaining calm while using logic to determine root causes and options.  He strikes me as a logical choice to make decisions on a global scale, but is handicapped by prejudice and ignorance.

Volodymyr Zelenskyy, a comic actor whose politics was expressed in satire, struck a nerve.  His election surprised many, even more so when Russians invaded he did not flee.  He displayed courage and organizing.  His first language is Russian and at some point he may be able to demonstrate forgiveness.   http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2022/06/servant-of-people-final-episodes.html

A woman who crossed my path is Chrystia Freeland.  She has a long run view and understands the lure of power.  She played second fiddle to the Prime Minister and made a bold move that forced him out. http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2013/01/plutocrats-by-chrystia-freeland.html

Yuval Noah Harari  has caught my attention for his understanding of human nature, where we came from and where we are headed.  He explains AI.  Does not subscribe to the idea of Jews being God's chosen people.  He is also openly gay and lives in Israel which may be a bonus, or a deterrent. http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2024/10/nexus.html

Mark Carney has recently come to global recognition.  Handling Trump is a real test, but Carney has done a fair balancing act.  He has drawn a few lines and diversified trade and defence

Of course others could have been mentioned, and there is no perfect choice.  Is the final decision maker the only leader?  Part of Trump's downfall will be attributed to his choice of advisors selected for loyalty, not expertise or level headedness.  That should have been a clue before the election.

In pre history leaders were chosen informally by followers recognizing competence first hand.  Expertise was acknowledged and different group members would lead different tasks.  Then we got civilized?  http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2014/07/selected.html

Since recorded history we have endured many monarchs or dictators and have developed concepts of democracy, but in general powerful people were able to use money, connections and sophistication to manipulate.  As my regular readers know, I advocate proportional representation, but even that only works with educated voters (but PR generally is more conducive to education).   http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2023/10/your-vote-neednt-be-wasted.html

There have been many dominant powers, but they all eventually are diminished.  Fareed Zakaria refers to the British Empire whose power was global didn't collapse from outside attack, but did get spread too thin to manage.

At some future date it seems possible that mankind could galvanize over climate change.  At the moment it seems not enough powerful people are suffering, but it seems likely the suffering will steadily increase. The Iran war is steering more nations and people to seek alternatives to fossil fuel.  We are still headed for climate disaster, but sufficient people do not yet realize that.

To survive the world needs more long term thinking and more respect for science.  And above all we need to co-operate for everyone's best interest.  Hate hurts everyone and has all too often been used as a tool to benefit a small number of people.

Nelson Mandela presented what we need.  A collaborator with a vision.

Thank you Fabrice for getting me on this track. 





Wednesday, September 24, 2025

The Crisis of Canadian Democracy

Most of "The Crisis of Canadian Democracy" dissects the many serious faults in Canadian democracy with a few solutions.  The last chapter is about the crises we are facing, including Trump and why we need to change our approach to democracy to better deal with the future.  

Explaining his solutions he also admits that those who have the power to make changes know they owe their power to the present system.  It appears most Canadians are not conscious of our deficiencies and perhaps an increased awareness will be a start.  But we are running out of time. 

With a poor democratic structure we are less fit to resist Trump.  One wild speculation has been he would be satisfied with luring Alberta to join America.  Blind patriotism may not be enough.

This post cannot be a summary of all Andrew's good ideas, but hopefully will inspire some to read the book and others to be more conscious of our deficiencies.

 The Canadian Prime Minister has too much power.  As with all party leaders he has power as to who gets nominated in ridings and obviously on cabinet ministers.  Cabinet members especially, and M.P.'s are expected to go along with government positions.  He or she has the power to call an election (at their convenience).  The power of prorogue to stop opposition, very effectively done by Stephen Harper and Justin Trudeau.

Andrew feels the leader should be decided by the caucus as they have the best understanding of the job and the character required.  This is not a new idea, but got lost with the lure of money making recruiting new members.

Parliament is where ideas get discussed and debated and where some local concerns can be aired, but time devoted to it is diminishing.  Parliament is where the government has to answer to the people, but when not sitting grievances pile up.  Canada has fallen behind other nations.  One reason has been elections that even once resolved Canada takes longer than most nations to resume Parliament.

Chrystia Freeland was shabbily treated, because Justin could, and this helped finally to force him to resign.  Before she got into politics a book (and some tv. appearances) got my attention http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2013/01/plutocrats-by-chrystia-freeland.html

Andrew states "Conventional management theory teaches that the greater the size of the operation, the more important it becomes to delegate authority to subordinates."  Instead the Canadian government is centralizing power.  

The Supreme Court is appointed by the Prime Ministers.  One of their roles is judicial review that now is more important because of the Charter of Rights and specifically the "notwithstanding rule."  Without allowing for exceptions to the charter it would not have been agreed upon.  Nonetheless it is subject to abuse.  The Quebec Bill 21 wants to ban religious garb such as turbans, hajibs or skullcaps from public service.  Recently I learned some in Alberta would like to place restrictions on transexuals.  The federal government is supposed to protect all citizens from prejudice.

The Senate is all appointed and subject to Prime Ministerial favoritism.  Andrew feels it should be elected, but not based on population.  Some groups have special rights, but not majority clout.  An example might be the indigenous.  My opinion, this could offset some of the power of majorities to overlook human rights.  It might also help to honor agreements that have been made to Prince Edward Island and francophone Quebec

A few points on election campaigns.  Journalists put too much emphasis on the horse race aspects.  Andrew feels they should be explaining policies and characters to help voters sort for their big decision

He also feels debates should be a bigger part of the campaign.  The networks know debates take away from profitable ad time.  The debates should be managed by a non partisan group.  Ideally held once a week on different topics and all should be bilingual.  The networks should not have any control over content or format, but obligated as part of their license agreement.

Essentially democracy means the voice of the common citizen should be heard and respected, but all votes are not equal.  To start with the size of ridings is not equal.  Canada  has a greater variance than in other countries, for example from the 2021 census, the smallest riding is in Labrador with 27,000 people while the largest is Edmonton-Wetaskiwin with more than 209,000 people meaning it takes more voters in some ridings to elect a member.  

Another serious concern is that most votes are wasted.  In our first past the post electoral system the decision is made by plurality and not majority.  In actual practice it is very normal for the minority parties to have gained more votes  than the winner, yet their votes do not count and thus their views are not represented.  Also the winner usually has unneeded votes that are also wasted.  Many voters use strategic voting meaning they vote for a secondary choice in order to lessen the chances for a disliked party.  

Proportional representation is a concept to remedy the wasted votes plus the need for strategic voting and has been found to actually increase voter turnout.  Unfortunately those in power don't like this idea as they got their power from the current system.  Still hundreds of countries have adopted a variation allowing a more realistic opinion of their voters to be reflected by their government.

Andrew also likes the idea of mandatory voting as the government is supposed to represent the whole country and not just the educated and informed.  

As Andrew points out Canada's future is full of challenges such as pandemics, climate change, Parti Quebecois, a European War, aging population and immediately Donald Trump.  The stronger our democracy the better we can weather the storms.  He also warns that the future will call for sacrifices (that might be painful).

An earlier blog regarding proportional representation:  http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2023/10/your-vote-neednt-be-wasted.html

Israel has long been used against the proportional representation concept.  In truth Jewish voters and elected representatives dominate Arabs, but nonetheless there are occasionally opportunities:  http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2021/07/is-israel-such-bad-example-for.html

Thursday, October 6, 2022

Freezing Order

First learned about "Freezing Order" (2022) when author, Bill Browder was interviewed by Steve Paikin.  It does clarify some events noted in earlier blogs.  We all knew that Putin could not be trusted and that somehow he was linked to Donald Trump.  Much has already been public, but much has either been buried or dismissed.

Bill Browder is an investment manager/owner.  He saw an opportunity when the Soviet Union broke up.  He moved to Moscow and set up a fund, the Hermitage Capital Management.  At one time he was the largest foreign investor in Russia.  That ended in 2005. One problem was that he had to deal with corruption that undercut his investments so he developed ways of minimizing corruption, but soon found that authorities weren't on board. 

The Russian government forced Browder out of Russia.  Sergei Magnitsky, a lawyer working with the Hermitage fund stayed and became an annoyance (obstacle) uncovering corruption.  He was imprisoned and tortured and died November 16, 2009.  

Browder took upon himself to fight back and organized to set up the Magnitsky Act as a memorial to the misdeed uncovered by the honest Sergei Magnitsky.  In effect the government could freeze funds that had been illegally obtained and laundered.  Obama signed the Magnitsky Act into law on December 14, 2012 and illegal assets started to be frozen.  Putin reacted by blocking adoption of Russian children by Americans.  He also put Browder and the dead Magnitsky on trial to prove they are the ones that stole money.  In other words they were accused of committing the crimes that they were investigating.

When the Panama Papers came out it was learned that Sergei Rodulgun, a cellist had come across billions of dollars.  It turns he was the closest friend of Putin and perhaps the only one he could trust with his money.  On his job Putin was limited not only by his salary, but any public means of making money.   He is in fact was one of the richest men in the world.  He went to great lengths to keep his source and total wealth secret.

Browder was harassed with the Russians even hiring top notch American lawyers as part of their arsenal.  They made an effort to uncover Browder's Russian contacts.  As you may recall those who crossed Putin tended to fall from high buildings or be poisoned or even be shot.  

One name that crossed Browder in court was Natalia Vaselnitskaya who claimed she worked for private business, but later seemed more likely she worked directly for the Russian government. 

The infamous dossier seems likely to have some truth to it, but has been dismissed.  Browder was told that Russian disinformation sources were able to put in some misinformation that allowed others to focus on the untruths as if they proved the whole thing was false.  

The Helsinki conference where Trump and Putin met, discussed behind closed doors and took part in a press conference revealed another link.  After Robert Mueller indicted 12 GRU agents for interfering in American election Putin was asked if they could be extradited and replied that sure they could be interviewed in Russia, if Bill Browder could be indicted.  Trump remained silent.  Later when told other names to be extradited Trump thought that was "an incredible offer."  What hold did Putin have over Trump--for a few clues check:  http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2019/06/house-of-trump-house-of-putin.html

The well known Trump Tower meeting had been orchestrated by Natalia Vaselnitskaya the Russians hinting they might have some damaging information on Hillary Clinton.  Clinton had not only criticized Putin, but was also a supporter of the Magnitsky Act.  Paul Manafort noted that Browder's name was a topic, but the underlying concern was the Magnitsky Act.  When revealed the Trump team claimed it was about adoptions.

Browder's legal problems were ongoing and harassment never ending,  At one point Browder was accused of murdering Magnitsky, although earlier they claimed the death had been from natural causes.  Browder was tried in abstentia and of course was guilty and altogether he was sentenced to a few decades of heavy labor.  However he eventually got 34 nations to adopt their own version of the Magnitsky Act.  The Act was not just against Russians, but has been used against the Saudi assassins of Jamal Kashoggi and organizers of Uigher concentration camps in China.

Chrystia Freeland (who speaks Russian) was one of the people behind the scenes among other activities advocating for Canada adopting its own Magnitsky Act.  More on her:  http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2013/01/plutocrats-by-chrystia-freeland.html

As I write this, Putin has signed legislation that annexes parts of Ukraine, ironically while the Ukrainian army has been steadily reclaiming much of this land.  His unprovoked attack on Ukraine and his disregard for the truth proves he is unworthy to be a leader of a great nation.  Or maybe it just proves if you have enough power you can do anything. 

An earlier blog about Putin and the truth:  http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2022/03/icarus.html

Thursday, October 8, 2015

REGULATIONS: HOW WE PROTECT OURSELVES AGAINST OURSELVES

We like to think that we are not selfish or at least we are fair.  Ha ha, are you sure?  It is easy to point to other people who are selfish and unfair, but if we look deep inside ourselves are we that much different?  The key factor often seems to be opportunity and I would concede part of that is our upbringing.  Most of us are taught the importance of fairness and we can agree with the Golden Rule that we should do on to others as we would have others do on to us.  But almost everyone of us knows someone who cheated and got away with it.  For myself:  http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2013/08/what-have-you-gotten-away-with.html

People are wonderful.  We can be creative, generous, and wise.  As a survival tool we are also self interested and protective or we wouldn't have made it this far.  A common refrain is that freedom is one of the most, if not the most desirable of aspirations.  The problem with our freedom is that all too often it infringes on other people's freedom.  Our freedom to do selfish or bad things can hurt other people.

Evolution has been portrayed as a struggle for survival of the fittest.  We now realize that survival often hinged on co-operation inside a group.  Human nature being what it is there was probably always an element of exploitation, but in the early days it was soon recognized that it is easier to survive (and thrive) as a member of a group than as an individual.  We learned that there is survival value in restraining our greed for the common good.

A key to human progression was producing more food than was needed for one person or even just one family.  Agriculture unleashed civilization as we know it.  Cities could develop, businesses could innovate and serve a variety of needs, and banding together people could protect themselves against outside forces.  Now many did not have to work as hard as others and could still prosper if they were smart.  The masses could organize against some abuses.  We came to rely on leaders.

And surely there were abuses.  We read about adulterating the value of coins, of tampering with weigh scales, of misleading promises and of the fact that often might is right.  While the masses were always interested in getting their fair share of resources, others were more clever or cold hearted to get more than their fair share.

We certainly hear the laments about how abusive regulations are.  Tamping down innovations and ambitions.  Yes there is a lot of truth in that, but it only tells part of the story.

Human nature has proved itself continuously that anyone can exploit their resources over others to gain an edge.  Often times this is admired and rewarded with gratitude and concrete advantages. Other times the perpetrator is thrown in jail.  Mostly it is not noticed and the perpetrator has gained some advantage, small or big.

Regulations attempt to keep a level playing field.  If you are an honest, hard working, but rational person you are concerned that your co-workers and your competitors might be cheating.  If they are thought to be unfairly exploiting opportunities you will be tempted to do so as well. The consumer would like to think that when they buy something or trust someone they are getting what they have been led to believe.

On the other hand regulation can create barriers for outsiders.  Those who have established themselves can make the rules.  In fact the most important edge someone achieved might be the ability to help set the rules.  Often the rules make it difficult for outsiders to make any inroad

Chrystia Freeland in her book, "Plutocrats" recounts the story of the rise and fall of the Venetian Empire.  It was founded with legal mechanism to encourage daring entrepreneurs out on long distance trade. You might remember Marco Polo and his father and uncle participated in this.  Everyone benefited from the profits of of the successful risk takers.  By 1500 Venice had lost much of its power.  Chrystia attributes it to the rise of oligarchs, many of whom were self made.  They wanted to entrench their power and wealth and closed opportunities for newcomers.

In ancient times we can read about adulterating coins and altering scales amongst many other tricks to persuade gullible consumers.  Today we are perhaps a little more sophisticated.

Newspaper headlines keep reminding us that those in power (and those who want to take a short cut to power) are always looking for an edge.  Volkswagen engineers found a way to pass pollution tests without actually having the expensive adjustments.  Back in 2008 after lobbying for de-regulation in the financial industry we had a major financial event that was negative for most people.

We tend to feel most comfortable with the status quo or the default position.  Disruptive innovations are by definition things that upset the apple cart and force the rest of us to adjust.  An example might be some green energy breakthroughs may hurt those who are deeply invested in fossil fuels.  You can read about the delicacy of the innovators dilemma at http://www.therealjohndavidson.com/2013/03/the-innovators-dilemma.html

Regulations have been touted as job killers.  Maybe, but they can have positive effects.  A company can only sell defective or harmful goods for so long before consumers stop buying or suffer other consequences.  The regulators are employed and in most cases paying taxes and protecting the public good and encouraging honest endeavors.

It is actually the presence of safety nets that allow some entrepreneurs to take a risk.  Take away the safety net and some innovations may seem too risky.  Safety net tools include unemployment insurance, food stamps, welfare.

After all is said and done regulation is a delicate balancing act.  Who do you trust?

Monday, January 28, 2013

PLUTOCRATS BY CHRYSTIA FREELAND

I was drawn to this book partly by the topic, but mainly by the author.  I had seen Chrystia on various American political shows and recently on TVO.  She made more sense (maybe because her opinions were more agreeable to me) than other more established talkers.

"Plutocrats" was more thought provoking (meaning I had to adjust my thinking) than anticipated.  As we all know the very rich are often thought of as not nice people.  However they do have their own justification and many of them are actually very helpful.

In fact many of them really did earn their advantages in life by contributing to the benefit of the rest of us 99%.  The really big winners are not so much inheritors of wealth as achievers.  In  modern global economy there are more opportunities to generate profit.  Some of them unfortunately are the result of transferring jobs to jurisdictions with lower wages and fewer cumbersome regulations or to robotics.

Most of us are pleased with how Steve Jobs and Bill Gates have made our lives more enjoyable, but with the productivity gains they have both brought about jobs have shifted.

Finance used to be little regarded, but is now the favored route of many to riches.  This is probably where the average person has the most resentment.  Most would acknowledge that financing is important and that there is a risk involved.  Part of the resentment might be the average person just can't see how playing with numbers justifies multi million dollar incomes.  Another big concern is the feeling that financiers have more political clout than the rest of us and have tilted the rules in their favour.

One anecdote near the end is of a ground breaking minority person who heads an Ivy League school and has been noted for boosting minority opportunities is quoted as not wanting to change alumni privileges as she has a grand daughter she wanted to help.  The point is that once someone hits a higher status they want to lock it in for perpetuity.

 Chrystia ends with a story on the Venetian Empire. It started with a legal mechanism to encourage daring entrepreneurs out on long distance trade trips that allowed Venice to be an international dominant force. Everyone did benefit from the wealth brought in by successful risk takers.  We all know of Marco Polo from this era.  By 1500 Venice lost most of its power.  The reason was that the oligarchs who were mostly self made men wanted to entrench themselves and close down opportunities for newcomers.  I think this allegory speaks to modern times.  It is not so much that we need to shut down great wealth, but that we need to keep open opportunities.  That means equality, education, a safety net and a long term view of what is good for humankind.

A personal note:  While I was preparing this blog my page views crossed the 10,000 mark.  Google has given me a global reach.  I am not sure if many readers gained any new information or felt my viewpoints were worth the effort.  It is astonishing where you all come from--Canada, United States, Ukraine, Russia, Germany, China, India, Israel, United Kingdom, France, Australia, Brazil, Saudi Arabia, Ethiopia,  and even more.